Several years ago, my brother-in-law and his wife adopted a boy from an orphanage in Russia. Now 17, and having lived most of his life in the United States, Kolya announced recently that he didn’t want to go see the latest installment of the “Indiana Jones” movies. When asked why, his response was simple:
“Because the bad guys are Russians.”
At first, I thought he was kidding. It’s just a movie… light-hearted entertainment. As in all of the other “Indiana Jones” movies, the characters are simply “caricatures”, comic exaggerations designed to generate a laugh. Take, for example, Dr. Jones himself – a mild-mannered archeology professor at an ivy-covered college by day, but a hard-drinking, fist-throwing, gun-shooting, whip-cracking adventurer by night… who hates snakes!
C’mon. You only find those types among United Methodist pastors!
In the first movie, the bad guys were Nazis. The film could almost have been a WWII-era propaganda film, with the very obvious plot of good (i.e. America) triumphing over evil (i.e. the Nazis). Yet as far as I know, people of German-American descent did not cry out in protest over the comic mis-characterization of that unfortunate chapter in their history.
As WWII concluded and the Nazis were defeated, America’s next big threat came from Russia – the Soviet Union. This latest Indiana Jones movie is set during the Cold War, so it seems appropriate that the “bad guys” would be Soviets. If it had been set any time after 2001, the “bad guys” would be turban-wearing Taliban terrorists.
You’ll find a similar progression of enemies in the James Bond movies.
But the Indiana Jones series is as much comedy as adventure. To that end, each of the movies has been filled with stereotypes of people around the world – from the fez-wearing, black market businessmen in the grottos of Morocco to the mud-covered, poison-dart blowing natives in the jungles of this latest movie.
And the aliens – taken straight out of the “X-Files”.
I would dare say that if the Indiana Jones series has misrepresented anyone, they have misrepresented pretty much everyone… throughout the galaxy!
But Kolya was serious. I don’t think it’s simply a matter of being “politically correct”. These were his people being unfairly maligned. It wasn’t funny to him. Truth be told, would we laugh if the roles were reversed and the Russians were the heroes?
And is it possible Kolya was catching some grief from his schoolmates who were unable to distinguish between the fantasy of a movie villain and the reality of a flesh-and-blood Russian-American right there in their midst?
Does what we call “entertainment” inadvertently inspire racial and ethnic misconceptions?
In December I attended a conference on diversity at Lake Junaluska, N.C. It was sponsored by the Southeast Jurisdiction of the UMC. It was a joy and privilege to celebrate the heritage of multiple ethnic groups represented there – Asian, Hispanic, Native American, African-American – and to worship God using their traditions. I came away from the event feeling like I had experienced a brief glimpse of what heaven must be like, and wishing that all of our churches could be so diverse and inclusive.
But one presentation almost ruined the event for me. We had already heard a great deal about how Native Americans have suffered at the hands of the “white man”. One woman told of the pain of being ostracized by both whites and Native Americans because she was a “half-breed”. We could feel her pain.
Then a Native American pastor, with a flair for the dramatic and a gift of humor, shared with the gathering his hurt at the hands of an ignorant white man – the man had continually referred to him as “chief”, referred to the native garb as a “costume”, and did the hand-raised “How?” – codified as an authentic “injun” greeting in early westerns.
I was right there with him, feeling righteous anger at this insensitive exchange. But then my native brother referred to the annoying little man as a “red-neck”.
Hey, wait a minute! That’s “my people” he’s insulting!
Seems it’s only funny when it’s the other ethnic group being insulted.
Speaking of “red-necks”, a television commercial for a local auto dealer recently announced he is giving away a free shotgun with every pick-up truck purchased. Lord help us!
But maybe Kolya has a point. Maybe it’s time to put away the stereotypes – even the funny ones!
I haven’t researched this, but I’m guessing that not every Russian is named “Boris” or “Natasha”… not every young black man with his pants bagging around his knees is a gang-banger… not every Muslim in America is a member of a “sleeper cell” waiting for an opportunity to destroy America… not every pickup truck owner wants a shotgun.
But how will we know until we look within ourselves and confess our own misconceptions and prejudices? How will we know who these people really are until we reach out and invite them into an authentic relationship? How will we know who they really are until we listen to their stories and hear how they have been hurt by our all-too-casual stereotyping?