Today we were sent out to "teaching churches", picked from a list that might represent or be similar to our particular ministry setting. None of the choices really matched my context, but I enjoy visiting other churches, so I chose Ocoee Oaks UMC, a combination new church start and merged congregation.
At first, I was going to wear my School of Congregational Development nametag, but at the last minute decided to be just a normal "visitor". If this was a church we were supposed to learn from, I wanted to see how they treated visitors.
Arriving with only five minutes to spare, I made up my mind that I would never come back to Ocoee Oaks UMC even before the worship service began.
Parking wasn't a problem. There was plenty. And an interesting thing about parking lots in Florida, I've noticed, is that they reduce the amount of pavement by parking cars on grassy strips. More green space, more trees.
As I walked into the church, a lone member - the designated greeter - was standing in the middle of a large lobby. He acknoweldged me, but did not come over to shake my hand.
I moved on to the door of the sanctuary, but a woman stepped in front of me and struck up a conversation with the one usher at that door. I was unable to get a worship guide or get past her. Finally, the usher, seeing me trying to pass, reached around her and slipped me a worship guide. The woman never acknoweldged my presence.
Keep in mind it was now less than 5 minutes before worship time. I found a seat in a row that was fairly empty, allowing two seats between me and the family to my left. They did not ackowledge me. Then a woman came and sat next to them; she, too, ignored me.
But here's what took the cake. A family of three appeared to my right. The woman looked across me to the woman and said, "So, you didn't save us a seat!" I offered to move down. At first, she said, no, but as they stood there trying to figure out their next move, she decided, "Yes, we want to sit next to our daughter." So I moved down the row to make room.
Sadly, she was the only one in the congregation to speak to me.
The worship service was designed to be contemporary, and it was okay for a small church. They had a three-piece band with a dozen vocalists, and a big screen with words to songs I did not know. The congregation seemed to enjoy it, but I didn't find it all that appealing.
Besides, Ocoee Oaks is not supposed to be a small church.
The history of the church is interesting. The conference bought the land in 1988, with the hopes of combining four nearby churches into one "regional" church. None of them cooperated. So the conference gave the property over for a new church start.
In 1995, Rev. Ernie Post was sent to start a new church on this property. Right off I noted he was a "fish out of water" - wearing the obligatory casual "Hawaiian Shirt" with dress slacks and black dress shoes. Turns out he was originally a pastor in Pennsylvania, but due to his wife's health, they needed to relocate to a warmer climate. He wrote up a proposal to be a new-church-start pastor and sent it to four different conferences. Florida called him to start West Oaks UMC, with hopes of creating a 3,000 t0 5,000 member congregation. Ernie's initial success jumped from 50-250 in the first 6 years.
But the city of Ocoee had other designs for the property, and although West Oaks had the cash in hand, the city dragged out the approval process for two years and added $400,000 worth of "necessary" improvements, which shut down the project.
When that was announced, eight of the top ten givers left the church.
In 2001, Ocoee UMC, a dying downtown congregation, proposed a merger. Ocoee was established in 1880, just 30 years after the first settlers came to the area. In the 1920s, race riots erupted and most blacks fled to Apopka; even 90 years later, few are willing to live or worship in Ocoee.
By August the merger was done and the church became known as Ocoee Oaks. Worship was initially held at the Ocoee Church building, which led to the departure of most of West Oaks' black members. The congregation continued to pursue building on the new site and in October of 2004, the held their first worship service in the new sanctuary.
At present, the congregation hasn't realized the dream of the conference. They offer three worship services (Sundays 8:30 a.m. traditional, Sundays 11 a.m. contemporary, Mondays 7 p.m. contemporary), but only draw 100-150 in each service... far from the 5,000 member congregation they are supposed to be. And for the last three years, growth has been flat.
But they keep that vision in mind. This morning they approved a $1 million building project to construct a pre-school. Neighborhood surveys indicate the need.
It was an interesting visit, but as I said above, I wouldn't go back. Which should be a wake-up call for all our congregations. Most visitors make up their minds about a church within the first 10 minutes of leaving their vehicles.
You say you're a friendly church. Are you really?
Or do you just greet your friends?
Would I feel welcome at your church... enough to come back a second time?
Just for comparison, I've been to Margaritaville three times this week. Hmmmm... what does that say?